Who was Freud?
When I read The Interpretation of Dreams, I recognized the web of deception he was weaving. ... I was totally versed in his manipulative logic and rhetoric. ... there was a man hiding behind a mask ... a man cannot write about sexuality the way Freud does and be so dispassionate toward it.
Peter J. Swales. in Malcolm, Janet, In The Freud Archives, (1984, p. 118).
Freud in 1938. Still going strong.
The real secret of my work...
Freud was a very complex, and, also, indeed, a very evil, person who, by any means available to him, wanted to have success in life, and he did.
If you want to learn about the true Freud, reading the Freud biographies won't take you there. Rather, follow the advice of the "great man". This is what he wrote about how to find out about the "true"Freud.
I have in any case been more open and frank in some of my writings (such as The Interpretation of Dreams and The Psychopathology of Everyday Life) than people usually are who describe their lives for their contemporaries or for posterity. *
And, this is how, to a visiting Italian writer, Freud explained his "secrets".
I taught others the virtue of confession and have never been able to lay bare my own soul. I wrote a short biography, but more for purposes of propaganda than anything else, and if ever I did make a fragmentary confession, it was in Traumdeutung — 'the Divining of Dreams.' Nobody knows or has ever guessed the real secret of my work. **
But, maybe, a century later, somebody did?
* SE 20, p. 73, Postscript (1935).
** Papini, Giovanni, A visit to Freud, May 8, 1934, pp. 98-99. In Ruitenbeek, Hendrik Marinus, Freud as We Knew Him, (1973).
... the subject of my investigations was an exceedingly bizarre, complex, and devious individual —indeed a man of such masterful artifice that probably to most mortals he will forever remain inscrutable...
Peter J. Swales in Malcolm, Janet, In The Freud Archives, (1984, pp. 133-134).
Why research Freud almost a century after his death?
Freud's ideas had a great influence on shaping the Western society that, bizarrely, for most of the 20th century, remained under Freud's mesmerising (and evil) spell. No wonder, considering that Freud was mentally ill, that our society looks the way it does.
As a result, Freud's odd idea, among others, that we aren't entirely consciously responsible for our actions, permeates our society affecting, not only, but in particular, our justice system, often excusing, or finding extenuating circumstances for, inexcusable criminal actions. Unlike in the past, when the society exclusively judged a person’s deeds, nowadays, we also "blame" the person’s past, in particular, his or her childhood, for whatever he/she had done. Leniency is our new motto. The perpetrator, rather than the abused person, is the victim.
Bizarrely, Freud's ideas - reflecting his both criminal, and perverse, character - that criminals are ruled by their subconscious, and that perversions are normal, have changed Western society into acceptance of what not long ago, before Freud's time, was considered criminal, insane or deviant.
I was unable to keep a secret.
The Interpretation of Dreams
SE V, p. 482.
The interpretation of fake dreams
The most revealing of all Freud's works is his book about dreams. Although titled, The Interpretation of dreams, it is nothing of the sort. Under the pretense of analysing dreams, Freud revealed his own perversions and criminality. This is how he explained the subject of the book:
I must ... resort to my own dreams as a source of abundant and convenient material, furnished by a person who is more or less normal, and containing references to many incidents of everyday life.
And the keywords are more or less normal. Realising his insanity, Freud often referred to his abnormality in his letters to Fliess, and in his early writings, also in his dream book.
Now comes the confession of what the book is really about: One has a comprehensible aversion, Freud explained, to exposing so many intimate details of one’s own psychic life ... [and] the indiscretions which I must commit,
Freud doesn't say that he has an aversion to exposing the intimate details of his dreams, instead stating that he will reveal what goes on in his psychic life, as it will be apparent to any scrupulous reader, including sexual, perverted, and criminal indiscretions.
If one wants to learn about the true Freud, one should read his earliest writings.
* Freud, Sigmund, The Interpretation of Dreams, (1913, p. 17).
She took it all with her... maybe not all...
Able to keep the family secrets
This is what Anna, Freud's faithful daughter - and de facto, third wife, after his mother, Martha, married to Freud, and the second de facto, Freud's sister-in-law, Minna - had to say about her unwillingness to recount her life with Freud.
I get letters from strangers from time to time, urging me to write my memoirs, almost as if it were my duty to do it. But, of course, that is the last thing in the world that I would be able to do.
This was her explanation:
I cannot share my feelings with the reading public and there is too much feeling bound up with the past, and above all the part of the past in which others would be interested. So I allow myself the privilege of taking it all with me. *
And the past that others, above all, would be interested in, that she could not reveal was, without a doubt, related to her father's perversions and criminality, and her (incestuous) relationship with him.
* Gardiner, M. Personal Tributes. Bulletin of the Anna Freud Centre 6, pp. 51–105, (1983, p. 65), quoted in Anna Freud: Gedichte – Prosa – Übersetzungen edited by Brigitte Spreitzer, and Daniel Benveniste, The Interwoven Lives of Sigmund, Anna and W. Ernest Freud; reviewed by Michael Molnar. Edinburgh University Press, Volume 18, Issue 2. "https://www.euppublishing.com/doi/10.3366/pah.2016.0191" 27,10.2024.
Uncovering the true Freud
Freud wasn't hiding his true evil nature. Anyone who has an average IQ, provided he/she is using their mental God-given equipment, will be able to realise that Freud was not only a fraud, but also a liar, forger, plagiarist, pervert, and murderer. Have I forgotten something? Freud was the first to point out all of his secrets he revealed in his writings. Here is the instruction how to read Freud:
He that has eyes to see and ears to hear may convince himself that no mortal can keep a secret. If his lips are silent, he chatters with his finger-tips; betrayal oozes out of him at every pore. *
And Freud was, most certainly, mortal. Since you have eyes, start looking, since you have ears, start to listen. And find out the true Freud in the products of his fingertips.
Freud, Sigmund, Dora: an analysis of a case of hysteria, (1963, p. 96).